MacOS – Almost all Functions in Numbers on MacOS Give Me Syntax Errors

macosnumbers

Almost all functions I try to use in Numbers give me a syntax error with no explanation what is wrong (red triangle with exclamation mark, only says "The formula contains a syntax error." when clicked). I'm on MacOS, NOT in the iPad version and have version 10.3.5 on Big Sur.

I tried UPPER("foo") and it displays FOO. So this gives me confidence that I know how to invoke functions.

enter image description here

results in

enter image description here

However then I actually wanted to use the find function. I try FIND("e", "where on earth") which is literally copied and pasted from the function help. All it does is give me an error.

enter image description here

results in

enter image description here

As said, all it gives me for details is this:

enter image description here

For reference the function help says in the example section

Examples

=FIND("e", "where on earth") returns 3 (“e” is the third character in the string “where on earth”).

Surely it must be something very basic I'm missing. When I copy and paste the same function in, say, Google Sheets, it's working perfectly.

Best Answer

Try using ; as a separator between parameters instead of ,.

If you start typing the function name in a cell and let it autocomplete you should also be able to see which separator will work and how the function should look.

It seems that in locales with a comma as a decimal point the separator for functions is different. The same thing happens in Microsoft Excel which is why I knew to look for it.