How does BitTorrent work with only outbound connections

Overview of how bittorrent works:

• You have peers and a tracker. All peers together at any given moment are the swarm. The usual situation is one or a few peers has the complete fileset and wishes to make it available to other peers.

• A peer acquires a .torrent file, which will have among other things A) the SHA-1 hash of the fileset, B) the URL of the tracker, and C) the number of pieces that the file is broken into, as well as an SHA-1 hash of every piece. The size of the pieces are determined by the torrent itself.

• The peer then connects to the tracker using the URL specified in the torrent. The tracker responds with a list of peers. Trackers talk HTTP over port 80 or 443.

• The peer then selects another peer, using the information from the tracker, and contacts it directly to set up an exchange session, attempting to get a piece. Note that exchange sessions are directly done by the peers and the tracker is NOT involved in the transfer. The tracker only provides information.

• Once the peer has a piece, it verifies it against the SHA-1 hash, and writes it to the file. It can then offer that piece when selecting another peer. Subsequent exchange sessions involve "trading" pieces. I believe peers will generally only give you the first piece if you have no other pieces.

• The peer reconsults the tracker every so often to get an updated list of peers. The peer does not have to wait for one exchange to finish before starting another one if it has multiple pieces, so once the peer has a bunch of pieces the transfer can really speed up. This is why torrents start slow but gain speed quickly as the peer acquires pieces.

• When a peer has all the pieces, the entire file is verified against the fileset SHA-1 hash. Then, it becomes a seeder, and is now doing nothing but helping the fileset be more highly available. Peers that do not have all the pieces are leechers.

• If a torrent has no seeds, it is dead, although if a complete copy of the file exists between all pieces held by all peers they will eventually trade to get a complete copy amongst themselves.

• The SHA-1 hash is how the tracker and peers "know" which file is supposed to be swarmed. Filenames in the torrent aren't used to identify the data. Pieces that don't verify against the hases in the .torrent file are thrown out. Peers that continually send bad pieces are snubbed by other peers and will eventually not be able to connect to anyone in the swarm.

• A smaller piece size means the torrent is more robust since peers can trade pieces quicker, but it also means more hashes of pieces in the .torrent file have to be listed and therefore the .torrent file can be large.

• If you are publishing something via BitTorrent, it's best to seed the file as long as you wish to make it available. Other peers will be helping you, since most BitTorrent software implements algorithms that favor trying to spread things among as many peers as possible to maximize conncurrent connections. In this way BitTorrent can help you publish things and save bandwidth costs.

Based on both of the points you said, I believe The following:

For the second point only:

Many NAS Devices with built in BitTorrent Clients work, but, are not very good. It is possible that it does not support DHT and the tracker you are connecting to is either offline or the file does not have any peers.

Your NAS either does not support UPnP, or you have UPnP disabled on your router, or you have not set up your firewall ports correctly.

The trackers you are connecting to are private and/or have some kind of status that they are returning but your client is not showing the message (e.g. wait time).

However when I also consider the first point combined with the second:

I believe that your NAS does not have an active internet connection. If you do not have DHCP active on it, make sure it's gateway and DNS are set correctly.

This would explain why it can not download/access .Torrent files via URL but you can put them there from your LAN, however, they do not progress at all.

I think I have covered all the possible reasons, I believe the last paragraph is the real reason, but, unless your NAS has a command prompt or any way to ping a site, I am not sure how you can test.

All this being said, if you turn your machine(s) off at night and just want the NAS to be a low powered Torrent client, fair enough - however, I have to say that a full torrent client such as Utorrent will give you a much better experience.