Bash – Why Does echo [9876543210] Display 1 4 5 6?

bashechopatternsshellwildcards

Please explain why 1 4 5 6 is displayed for the last four echo statements? I hit this by accident once, but I am now curious as to why this behavior occurs.

These statements work as expected (for me).

$ echo [ 9876543210 ]  
[ 9876543210 ]

$ echo [237890]  
[237890]

These echo statements consistently display 1 4 5 6. Is there something special about these numbers?

$ echo [9876543210]  
1 4 5 6

$ echo [abcd9876543210ghi]  
1 4 5 6

$ echo [-123456-]  
1 4 5 6

$ echo [-7654321-]  
1 4 5 6

Thanks!

The possible duplicate is related and helpful, but not a duplicate. The possible duplicate is from the perspective of an rm command. This question is from the perspective of a perceived "weird behavior" of an echo command. The underlying answer for both is globbing. Someone searching for issues with an echo command would not easily find the rm question, but would more likely land here.

Best Answer

The open bracket [ is a special character to the shell; it opens up a pattern matching algorithm that says "match any of the characters inside the brackets". Because you have 4 files named as: 1, 4, 5, and 6 in your current directory, when the characters inside the brackets contain any of those digits, your shell replaces the pattern-match with those filenames. When you instead use echo [ 9876543210 ] you are calling echo with 3 parameters: [, 9876543210, and ].

You should quote your echo statement's parameters to prevent the shell from seeing it as a pattern matching request.

$ echo '[9876543210]'
[9876543210]

(or remove the files named 1, 4, 5, and 6 -- but that's a workaround to demonstrate the behavior, not a fix).

Related Solutions

Bash – How to print only certain commands from a bash script as they are run

When I write more complex bash scripts, I use a little function to run commands that will also print the commands run into a logfile:

runthis(){
    ## print the command to the logfile
    echo "$@" >> $LOG
    ## run the command and redirect it's error output
    ## to the logfile
    eval "$@" 2>> $LOG 
}

Then, in my script, I run commands like this:

runthis "cp /foo/bar /baz/"

If you don't want a command printed, just run it normally.

You can either set the $LOG to a filename or just remove it and print to stdout or stderr.

Bash – Conditional execution block with || and parentheses problem

What you're searching is something like this:

[ "$USER" = "x" ] || { echo "Time to bail"; exit 1; }

The { list; } statement executes the commands in the given list in the current shell context. No subshell is created, unlike in the ( list ) notation. An exit call between parentheses will exit that subshell and not the parent shell itself.

The examples in your question with the if-statement on one line or multiple lines are syntactically correct. I cannot reproduce that behavior. It doesn't matter how many lines there arre; the if-statement never starts a subshell in its body.

BTW: I added double quotes to the variable in the condition, because when the variable $USER is empty, the construct would expand to [ = "x" ] which is not valid. With double quotes it expands to [ "" = "x" ].

Best Answer

Related Solutions

Bash – How to print only certain commands from a bash script as they are run

Bash – Conditional execution block with || and parentheses problem

Related Question