Ubuntu – Ubuntu with spyware


Richard Stallman states that Ubuntu "has installed surveillance code".
See: Ubuntu Spyware -What to Do?

Is this true?

I agree with him that "Any excuse Canonical offers is inadequate….".

Best Answer

Depends on your point of view. The controversy is over the "unity shopping lens". The shopping lens lets you look for "things" right from your computer. So if you look for "candles" you will get results, even though it's not a file or app. You will be presented with a choice to buy candles.

The real problem isn't that this lens exists, stuff like this has existed for a long time, the problem is the dashboard includes the results by default. So when you press the super key and the dash in unity pops up you type "can" and you get some applications, some files, and some amazon search results. You can scope you search to just files, or just applications, but by default, you search for everything (including shopping results).

Canonical has stated that the results go to their server, are made "more" anonymous and then sent to amazon. With Canonical acting as a go between.

The truth is it's probably not a totally bad idea. It would be nice to press super, type Mountain Dew, and have someone bring me a cold can of caffeine. However, the implementation leaves a lot to be desired. Most notably that it's on by default. It smacks of evil marketing, and it is quite offensive to many Linux users.

The good news is that it's very easy to remove or turn off.

From system setting, under privacy, disable "Internet searches".

It that's not good enough you can sudo apt-get remove unity-shopping-lens

Personally, I have it turned off and everything works fine. I do find it very annoying that my OS had "ads" in them, but at the same time, I can see how, properly matured, it could be friggin' awesome.

Honestly, we will just have to wait and see how the general community plays out, and rather it's accepted as the first step to a more awesome feature or totally unacceptable data mining.

A few other things to keep in mind:

  • It only effects Unity (Ubuntu default Desktop Environment)
  • It's easy to turn off
  • Ton's of other "searchers" existed before hand, this is just one that Canonical supports and makes use of
  • Stallman is a bit of a nut on some topics, and has a history of going, what most would consider 100% overboard on some issues.
  • The lens in question is about the same as the amazon store plugin in Amarok, Banshee, Rhythmbox, etc.
  • There are tons of people who want this feature and add it in via scripts, extensions, and add-ons.
  • Ubuntu's only real sin is having it on by default, and handling the PR extreamly poorly.

This article and the related ones may help you to decide.

Related Question