Macos – Why are some (all?) files bigger on Mac OS X

First of all, I wonder if the 1 MB is correct: true, Finder's Show Info tells you this, but in Terminal the file sizes are always just half of that. Odd.

The size is due to embedded icons. Note that an alias to an application (more precisely: an application bundle) might be much smaller than an alias to a plain folder. Hence, I guess plain folders use a higher definition icon than, for example, iTunes does. And indeed, if you change the icon of the source, the icon of the alias is not changed.

In Terminal you'll see:

ls -l@

drwxr-xr-x   2 arjan     staff       68 Nov 14 09:20 MyFolder
-rw-r--r--@  1 arjan     staff   519012 Nov 14 09:20 MyFolder alias
    com.apple.FinderInfo         32 
    com.apple.ResourceFork   518659 

drwxr-xr-x   2 arjan     staff       68 Nov 14 09:26 MyOtherFolder
-rw-r--r--@  1 arjan     staff   519040 Nov 14 09:26 MyOtherFolder alias
    com.apple.FinderInfo         32 
    com.apple.ResourceFork   518679 

So: 4 bytes more in the "Resource Fork" for each letter in the file name, and on the file system things are padded a bit. That same Resource Fork also includes the icons. If you have the Apple Developer Tools installed:

DeRez "MyFolder alias" > MyFolderAlias.txt

That text file then shows you more than 32,000 lines of text that represents the icon.

(See also Ars Technica about HFS+. Without the Developer Tools, your can use xattr -l to kind of see what's in those extended attributes.)

There's now a better way!

See man dot_clean since OS X 10.5.

dot_clean -n . will not just delete the dot underbar files in and below the current directory, it'll merge their information into the parent file if it's not already there (and I infer that you want -n to also delete the dot underbar file if there is no matching native file).