What happens when you alter a table column’s length, but that length is already that length

The solution is dbms_redefinition package. Basically redefition will move, online, to a new table (called interim table), then move all dependent objets like indexes and last exchange the interim table with the original one.

What you have to do is:

• Create the interim table withe correct column definition
• Run redefinition
• Drop the old table

Use dbms_redefinition in the following way:

-- DETERMINE IF THE ORIGINAL TABLE CAN BE REDEFINED ONLINE
BEGIN
DBMS_REDEFINITION.CAN_REDEF_TABLE('SCHEMA','YOURTABLE', DBMS_REDEFINITION.CONS_USE_ROWID);   
END;
/

-- BEGIN THE REDEFINITION
BEGIN
DBMS_REDEFINITION.START_REDEF_TABLE(
UNAME => 'SCHEMA',
ORIG_TABLE => 'YOURTABLE',
INT_TABLE => 'INTERIM_YOURTABLE'
OPTIONS_FLAG => DBMS_REDEFINITION.CONS_USE_ROWID);
END;
/

-- IF THE TABLE HAD DEPENDENCIES (INDEXES ... CONSTRAINTS ... TRIGGERS)
-- THIS WOULD BE THE POINT AT WHICH THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN COPIED
DECLARE 
error_count pls_integer := 0;
BEGIN
DBMS_REDEFINITION.COPY_TABLE_DEPENDENTS('SCHEMA', 'YOURTABLE', 'INTERIM_YOURTABLE', 
dbms_redefinition.cons_orig_params, TRUE, TRUE, TRUE, FALSE, error_count);
DBMS_OUTPUT.PUT_LINE('errors := ' || TO_CHAR(error_count));
END;
/

-- FINISH THE REDEFINITION
exec DBMS_REDEFINITION.FINISH_REDEF_TABLE('SCHEMA','YOURTABLE','INTERIM_YOURTABLE');

If you run redefinition with SYSTEM user there is no problem. If you want to execute it with a less privileged user you have to trick some privileges in order to get it working. Privileges required are:

• Execute privilege to DBMS_REDEFINITION
• Create any table
• Alter any table
• Drop any table
• Lock any table
• Select any table

Tables with the following characteristics cannot be redefined online:

• [9.0.1]Tables with no primary keys
• Tables that have materialized view logs defined on them
• [9i] Tables that are materialized view container tables and AQ tables
• [10g] Tables that are replicated in an n-way master configuration can be redefined, but horizontal subsetting (subset of rows in the table), vertical subsetting (subset of columns in the table), and column transformations are not allowed.
• The overflow table of an IOT table
• Tables with fine-grained access control (row-level security)
• Tables with BFILE columns
• Tables with LONG columns can be redefined online, but those columns must be converted to CLOBS. Also, LONG RAW columns must be converted to BLOBS. Tables with LOB columns are acceptable.
• Tables in the SYS and SYSTEM schema
• Temporary tables

Other restrictions:

• A subset of rows in the table
• Only simple deterministic expressions, sequences, and SYSDATE can be used when mapping the columns in the interim table to those of the original table. For example, subqueries are not allowed.
• If new columns are being added with no column mappings, then they must not be declared NOT NULL until the redefinition is complete.
• There cannot be any referential constraints between the table being redefined and the interim table.
• Table redefinition cannot be done NOLOGGING.
• [10g] For materialized view logs and queue tables, online redefinition is restricted to changes in physical properties.
• You cannot convert a nested table to a VARRAY.

The Oracle Administrators Guide says the following:

Use the ALTER TABLE...MODIFY statement to modify an existing column definition. You can modify column data type, default value, column constraint, column expression (for virtual columns) and column encryption.

You can increase the length of an existing column, or decrease it, if all existing data satisfies the new length. You can change a column from byte semantics to CHAR semantics or vice versa. You must set the initialization parameter BLANK_TRIMMING=TRUE to decrease the length of a non-empty CHAR column.

If you are modifying a table to increase the length of a column of data type CHAR, realize that this can be a time consuming operation and can require substantial additional storage, especially if the table contains many rows. This is because the CHAR value in each row must be blank-padded to satisfy the new column length.

The Oracle SQL Language Reference has much more detail including the following:

You can change the data type of any column if all rows of the column contain nulls. However, if you change the data type of a column in a materialized view container table, then Oracle Database invalidates the corresponding materialized view.

You can always increase the size of a character or raw column or the precision of a numeric column, whether or not all the rows contain nulls. You can reduce the size of a data type of a column as long as the change does not require data to be modified.The database scans existing data and returns an error if data exists that exceeds the new length limit.

You can modify a DATE column to TIMESTAMP or TIMESTAMP WITH LOCAL TIME ZONE. You can modify any TIMESTAMP WITH LOCAL TIME ZONE to a DATE column.

If the table is empty, then you can increase or decrease the leading field or the fractional second value of a datetime or interval column. If the table is not empty, then you can only increase the leading field or fractional second of a datetime or interval column.

For CHAR and VARCHAR2 columns, you can change the length semantics by specifying CHAR (to indicate character semantics for a column that was originally specified in bytes) or BYTE (to indicate byte semantics for a column that was originally specified in characters). To learn the length semantics of existing columns, query the CHAR_USED column of the ALL_, USER_, or DBA_TAB_COLUMNS data dictionary view.

There is additional information and restrictions in the above documentation. Here is a demonstration of attempting to reduce the precision of a Number column and reduce the length of a Varchar2. You can try other changes so you will know what will happen.

--Setup.
DROP TABLE FOO;
CREATE TABLE FOO (BAR Number, BAR2 VARCHAR2(300));
INSERT INTO FOO (SELECT Level, RPAD(to_char(Level),10*Level,to_char(Level)) 
   FROM DUAL CONNECT BY Level <=20);
COMMIT;
SELECT * FROM FOO;

--Reduce Number to Number(10).
ALTER TABLE FOO MODIFY (BAR NUMBER (10));

--Reduce Varchar2(300) to Varchar2(100) (data would be truncated).
ALTER TABLE FOO MODIFY (BAR2 VARCHAR2(100));

--Reduce Varchar2(300) to Varchar2(200) (no data would be truncated).
ALTER TABLE FOO MODIFY (BAR2 VARCHAR2(200));

The alter statements have the following output:

ALTER TABLE FOO MODIFY (BAR NUMBER (10))
Error report:
SQL Error: ORA-01440: column to be modified must be empty to decrease precision or scale
01440. 00000 -  "column to be modified must be empty to decrease precision or scale"

ALTER TABLE FOO MODIFY (BAR2 VARCHAR2(100))
Error report:
SQL Error: ORA-01441: cannot decrease column length because some value is too big
01441. 00000 -  "cannot decrease column length because some value is too big"

table FOO altered.

Reduce precision by creating a new column.

ALTER TABLE FOO ADD (BAR3 NUMBER(10));
UPDATE FOO SET Bar3 = Bar;
ALTER TABLE FOO DROP COLUMN BAR;
ALTER TABLE FOO RENAME COLUMN BAR3 TO BAR;