OBSERVATION #1

Performance implications should become quickly apparent if the index pages of monitor.result have to experience two things:

• Experience 1) Swapping of the RAM making up the MyISAM Key Cache
• Experience 2) Rotation in and out of the MyISAM Key Cache (sized by key_buffer_size)

Experience 1 is virtually unavoidable. As for Experience #2, it could result in needed index pages being purged out of the MyISAM Key Cache in the face of more recent queries against other MyISAM tables. Those needed index pages more be brought back by querying the corresponding table. The two experiences togther could make for a slower-than-expected query on relatively small tables.

However, you could minimize or neutralize any ill effects of swapping by assigning the index of monitor.result by creating a dedicated MyISAM Key Cache. It will be a cache that will contain only index pages from monitor.result.

How do you do that ???

First, recall that you mentioned that the index usage for monitor.result was 2.29MB. You can create that dedicated key cache with that size with a little headroom, say 2.5MB. Let us create that key cache like this:

SET GLOBAL monitor_result_private_cache.key_buffer_size = 1024 * 512 * 5;
CACHE INDEX monitor.result IN monitor_result_private_cache;
LOAD INDEX INTO CACHE monitor.result;

This will perform the following steps:

1. Create the Key Cache
2. Assign the Key Cache to the MyISAM Table using LOAD INDEX INTO CACHE
3. Load the Index Pages of the Assigned MyISAM Table into its Corresponding Cache

It would conveniently keep the index pages of that table from ever leaving the cache. The only table index pages would leave is if INSERTs into monitor.result increases the contents beyond 2.5MB. You must choose enough headroom to accommodate many INSERTs into monitor.result.

OBSERVATION #2

I also noticed the index you laid out for monitor.result:

PRIMARY KEY (`server`, `request`, `recorded`, `ref_id`)

If any of your queries against monitor.result resemble something like this:

SELECT resoultion,value FROM monitor.result
WHERE server = 200 AND refid = 50 AND ... ;

You can speed queries by reordering the PRIMARY KEY

CREATE  TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `monitor`.`result` (            
  `server` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `ref_id` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `request` TINYINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `recorded` TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_TIMESTAMP ,            
  `resolution` TINYINT NOT NULL ,            
  `value` MEDIUMINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  PRIMARY KEY (`server`, `ref_id`, `request`, `recorded`) )            
ENGINE = MyISAM       

or adding a UNIQUE index

CREATE  TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `monitor`.`result` (             
  `server` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,             
  `ref_id` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,             
  `request` TINYINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,             
  `recorded` TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_TIMESTAMP ,             
  `resolution` TINYINT NOT NULL ,             
  `value` MEDIUMINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,             
  PRIMARY KEY (`server`, `request`, `recorded`, `ref_id`),
  UNIQUE KEY uniqndx1 (`server`, `ref_id`, `request`, `recorded`)
ENGINE = MyISAM             

If you add a UNIQUE index, you must double the dedicate keycache accordingly.

OBSERVATION #3

You mentioned a SATA drive. Good choice for archival, low-update historical data. Any MyISAM table on a SATA drive which has a dedicated keycache should not be bothered by the index lookup but the data retrival time from the drive would be up to you to benchmark to see if you could live with the running times.

Here is an alternative:

Create an index that has every column

CREATE  TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `monitor`.`result` (            
  `server` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `ref_id` SMALLINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `request` TINYINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  `recorded` TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_TIMESTAMP ,            
  `resolution` TINYINT NOT NULL ,            
  `value` MEDIUMINT UNSIGNED NOT NULL ,            
  PRIMARY KEY (`server`, `ref_id`, `request`, `recorded`, `resolution`, `value`) )            
ENGINE = MyISAM       

What does this do? It provides data retrieval of entire rows strictly from the index. Combining this with a dedicated keycache, you will essentially has the whole table in RAM. All queries would be fulfilled by the index and never touch the table, REGARDLESS of the table being on SAS, SATA, SSD, or even stone.

UPDATE 2012-01-26 18:18 EDT

Question 1: You may want to look into memcached. I believe that there is a version InnoDB with a memcached plugin. At least, that's what I heard.

Question 2: InnoDB is for transactional tables. If you have archive data, compressed MyISAM tables should fill the bill. In fact, you could look into the ARCHIVE storage engine.

Question 3: Storing an index on disk (MyISAM,InnoDB) is always standard and cannot be changed. You have use special commands or run special queries to preload caches.

Question 4: RAID-10 for high-writes, SSD for high-reads. Watch your disk surface temperatures !!!

Question 5: if the table is strictly for holding historical info, no need for overkill. As long as it is a table rarely read, no need for special caching considerations.

In most cases, crashing a MyISAM table is nothing more than throwing mud on the MyISAM file header. It keeps a running count of the number of times the file has been opened. It increments upon opening and decrements upon closing.

You may want to look at the value for open-files-limit. This is an option that you cannot dynamically set with mysqld running. It can be configured at startup. What is interesting is its explanation in the MySQL Documentation:

Changes the number of file descriptors available to mysqld. You should try increasing the value of this option if mysqld gives you the error Too many open files. mysqld uses the option value to reserve descriptors with setrlimit(). If the requested number of file descriptors cannot be allocated, mysqld writes a warning to the error log.

mysqld may attempt to allocate more than the requested number of descriptors (if they are available), using the values of max_connections and table_open_cache to estimate whether more descriptors will be needed.

By default, mysqld sets this values based on the OS and how many maximum open file handles mysqld believes the OS will give to it.

You can take a risk and raise that number in /etc/my.cnf and restart mysql. As mentioned in the MySQL Documentation, a warning will be posted.

Talk to your sysadmin to see if your OS can have its file handle limit raised.

Once you can get it raised, restart mysql and see if the open_files_limit was raised as well.