Sql-server – Text Storage and Database Design Optimization in a SQL Server Database

Here is some vanilla SQL:

CREATE TABLE RoomTypes
(
 RoomType VARCHAR(12) NOT NULL,
 UNIQUE (RoomType)
);

CREATE TABLE Zones
(
 Zone VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL,
 UNIQUE (Zone)
);

CREATE TABLE Rooms
(
 RoomType VARCHAR(12) NOT NULL,
 Zone VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL, 
 Name VARCHAR(30) NOT NULL, 
 UNIQUE (RoomType, Zone, Name), 
 FOREIGN KEY (RoomType) REFERENCES RoomTypes (RoomType),
 FOREIGN KEY (Zone) REFERENCES Zones (Zone)
);

CREATE TABLE NumberedRooms 
(
 RoomType VARCHAR(12) NOT NULL,
 Zone VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL, 
 Name VARCHAR(30) NOT NULL, 
 CHECK (RoomType = 'Numbered'),
 UNIQUE (Name), 
 UNIQUE (RoomType, Zone, Name),
 FOREIGN KEY (RoomType, Zone, Name) 
    REFERENCES Rooms (RoomType, Zone, Name)
);

CREATE TABLE AncillaryRooms 
(
 RoomType VARCHAR(12) NOT NULL,
 Zone VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL, 
 Name VARCHAR(30) NOT NULL, 
 CHECK (RoomType = 'Ancillary'),
 UNIQUE (Zone, Name), 
 UNIQUE (RoomType, Zone, Name),
 FOREIGN KEY (RoomType, Zone, Name) 
    REFERENCES Rooms (RoomType, Zone, Name)
);

The CHECK constraints will not be tested by mySQL e.g. do the tests yourself using triggers. Consider adding other tests e.g. that attribute Name in table NumberedRooms represents an integer.

The idea that every row in the supertype table Rooms will have exactly one row in the union of AncillaryRooms and NumberedRooms. This is merely implied e.g. have 'helper' procs to add rows to both super- and subtype tables as a single operation and use triggers to ensure it is done.

Note NumberedRooms has a simple key Name alone, whereas AncillaryRooms has a compound key on (Zone, Name). All three (non-lookup) tables have a key on (RoomType, Zone, Name) throughout, allowing further subtype tables to referencing them and maintain integrity by further testing for valid RoomType values.

I personally would use a model similar to the following:

The product table would be pretty basic, your main product details:

create table product
(
  part_number int, (PK)
  name varchar(10),
  price int
);
insert into product values
(1, 'product1', 50),
(2, 'product2', 95.99);

Second the attribute table to store the each of the different attributes.

create table attribute
(
  attributeid int, (PK)
  attribute_name varchar(10),
  attribute_value varchar(50)
);
insert into attribute values
(1, 'color', 'red'),
(2, 'color', 'blue'),
(3, 'material', 'chrome'),
(4, 'material', 'plastic'),
(5, 'color', 'yellow'),
(6, 'size', 'x-large');

Finally create the product_attribute table as the JOIN table between each product and its attributes associated with it.

create table product_attribute
(
  part_number int, (FK)
  attributeid int  (FK) 
);
insert into product_attribute values
(1,  1),
(1,  3),
(2,  6),
(2,  2),
(2,  6);

Depending on how you want to use the data you are looking at two joins:

select *
from product p
left join product_attribute t
  on p.part_number = t.part_number
left join attribute a
  on t.attributeid = a.attributeid;

See SQL Fiddle with Demo. This returns data in the format:

PART_NUMBER | NAME       | PRICE | ATTRIBUTEID | ATTRIBUTE_NAME | ATTRIBUTE_VALUE
___________________________________________________________________________
1           | product1   | 50    | 1           | color          | red
1           | product1   | 50    | 3           | material       | chrome
2           | product2   | 96    | 6           | size           | x-large
2           | product2   | 96    | 2           | color          | blue
2           | product2   | 96    | 6           | size           | x-large

But if you want to return the data in a PIVOT format where you have one row with all of the attributes as columns, you can use CASE statements with an aggregate:

SELECT p.part_number,
  p.name,
  p.price,
  MAX(IF(a.ATTRIBUTE_NAME = 'color', a.ATTRIBUTE_VALUE, null)) as color,
  MAX(IF(a.ATTRIBUTE_NAME = 'material', a.ATTRIBUTE_VALUE, null)) as material,
  MAX(IF(a.ATTRIBUTE_NAME = 'size', a.ATTRIBUTE_VALUE, null)) as size
from product p
left join product_attribute t
  on p.part_number = t.part_number
left join attribute a
  on t.attributeid = a.attributeid
group by p.part_number, p.name, p.price;

See SQL Fiddle with Demo. Data is returned in the format:

PART_NUMBER | NAME       | PRICE | COLOR | MATERIAL | SIZE
_________________________________________________________________
1           | product1   | 50    | red   | chrome   | null
2           | product2   | 96    | blue  | null     | x-large

As you case see the data might be in a better format for you, but if you have an unknown number of attributes, it will easily become untenable due to hard-coding attribute names, so in MySQL you can use prepared statements to create dynamic pivots. Your code would be as follows (See SQL Fiddle With Demo):

SET @sql = NULL;
SELECT
  GROUP_CONCAT(DISTINCT
    CONCAT(
      'MAX(IF(a.attribute_name = ''',
      attribute_name,
      ''', a.attribute_value, NULL)) AS ',
      attribute_name
    )
  ) INTO @sql
FROM attribute;

SET @sql = CONCAT('SELECT p.part_number
                    , p.name
                    , ', @sql, ' 
                   from product p
                   left join product_attribute t
                     on p.part_number = t.part_number
                   left join attribute a
                     on t.attributeid = a.attributeid
                   GROUP BY p.part_number
                    , p.name');

PREPARE stmt FROM @sql;
EXECUTE stmt;
DEALLOCATE PREPARE stmt;

This generates the same result as the second version with no need to hard-code anything. While there are many ways to model this I think this database design is the most flexible.