After installing Sierra and a number of other fonts from Google Web Fonts, I now see the 'question mark' against any list items either within the actual system UI and other applications such as Chrome.
Edit:
I have already attemped two possible solutions:
Best Answer
Run
sudo atsutil databases -remove
, then reboot.atsutil is the CLI for the font registration system. Resetting the database can help clear up errors like this. Also see Check mark disappeared from dropdowns.