I'm running into the problem accurately described here:
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4229655?start=0&tstart=0
Summary: I take a JPG image, use a selection tool to remove the background so that it will be transparent, and then save the image as a PNG. The image background is represented as black, instead of transparent.
The link there shows that it's a "color profile" bug – is there a correct color profile that supports transparency?
Best Answer
Even though this problem is old, I did figure out a solution that works (on Mojave at least, haven't tried it anywhere else).
Hope this helps anyone out there still struggling with this!