I've been experiencing a very annoying problem lately. Often, I've got my MacBook Pro connected to power when I'm working from the office. At home, I often leave it unplugged until the battery is too low to continue at which point I plug it in.
The problem occurs when my device is connected to a power supply. My battery indicator shows 100% charge which is fine. But sometimes the battery starts draining and the menu bar icon says "Battery not charging," even when it's connected to a wall socket, and it keeps draining until absolutely dry. It doesn't even warn me the battery is running low because it shows "Power source: Power adapter" which I guess disables the Operating system low-battery warning. This has happened on multiple occasions.
I've already tried several things, I've swapped chargers, swapped wall sockets, started with as few tools/apps running as possible. But the problem comes back. I also can't really tie this to a specific app or behavior, AFAIK.
Does anyone know what might be causing this behavior and what to possibly do about it?
Best Answer
There are two things that can be attributed to this:
Wrong charger
You are likely using the wrong power adapter; it's too "small" for your particular MacBook. Your machine requires the 87W power adapter.
If you take a look at Apple's support document Find the right power adapter and cable for your Mac notebook under the USB section, you'll notice that all of the adapters from the 29W that charges the MacBook to the 91W that charges the 16" MacBook Pro all look identical so it's quite easy to mix them up. While you can plug in any of these into any of the MacBook computers (plain, Air, or Pro) and while it will "charge," you won't get optimal results.
What you're experiencing is what's in the second point. The adapter is connected (and detected) but it simply cannot supply enough power to charge and for you use the computer at the same time. If you notice, Coconut battery is reporting that it's charging with only 49W, yet the battery isn't charging. You're likely using the 61W adapter. (That number is a misnomer because that current is what it's drawing from the power adapter current, not what's going to the battery).
Battery Health Management in Catalina
As of Catalina (10.15.5) Apple has implemented a feature called Battery Health Management that will stop charging and allow it to discharge to a predetermined charge (about 80%) before recharging again. This happens even while the charger is plugged in and working.
You can learn more about Catalina’s Battery Health Management feature in the Apple Support Document About battery health management in Mac notebooks
Therefore, assuming you're using the correct wattage charging adapter, this could be perfectly normal behavior.