I have a 5 year old Seagate USB2 drive for backups, used for a few months with time machine on my Retina MBP.
Lately, I've been getting an error that it was improperly ejected (I didn't actually eject it), and I can hear the drive churn endlessly on its own. I can't remount it, its power button doesn't respond, I have to power cycle it, then it mounts again and seems to work. Until the next incident.
Is it dying on me? It's old but has only been lightly used, until recently.
Best Answer
I've had a similar problem with a 2 TB Fantom drive. Worked flawlessly for years, then it started to spontaneously unmount for no apparent reason. Time Machine being on or off doesn't have an effect.
It had been chained through another USB device (a MiniStack drive), and simply by taking it off the chain and plugging it directly into the Mac, I solved the problem.
Before ditching the drive, try changing USB cables and changing the routing (even a different USB port on the Mac.) Five years is a bit old for a hard drive, but it's not unreasonable.