MacBook – Apple Repair Service Image of cracked bezel -or- what am I looking at

hardwaremacbook prorepair

A simple battery exchange for a 2014 15" Macbook Pro turned into a major repair – at least that is what Apple's Repair contractor claims. All I got after a very disappointing chat and call with Apple's Support Hotline was this blurry image – apparently the reason why they claim not replace the battery is that they would only to this along with repairing this:

Image from Apple Repair shop

Now, this image tells me nothing but hopefully someone here has an idea what I am looking at. Would I have been able to see the defect prior to sending it off? Would the Genius at the Apple Store have seen this? MBP ran perfectly fine with the exception of the bloated battery.

Best Answer

That image is hard to make out, but I trust the people in the process with Apple repair for a couple reasons. One, what's their incentive to be wrong - they get paid to repair product and make you happy. Also, they see things perfectly under inspection even if that photo is blurry.

  • I would make a decision - is it worth paying for this repair?

If so, call back and say you would like them to take much higher resolution photos and see if they can cover some or all the accidental damage, but you're willing to pay if not. Leave the decision for them.

If not, thank them for discovering the damage and ask for it returned unprepared, again that they check with people who had custody if they noticed anything.

Once you have it, then it's up to you to look over things and make a call. My experience is if Apple messes up, they fess up immediately, apologetically, have a very good suggestion how to make me whole. I've not had any experience that was bad and the bloated battery could have expanded and damaged things in transit - it's not likely, but it's the most likely thing I can consider based on many years using Apple to repair work and home computers.